TRIBUTE TO PHIL EVANS
Page 23
Counter
Did Emmett "carve" Louis? A half dozen well
known New Orleans musicians said "Yes". When
Louis was asked about this he said, "The only cat I
ever jammed with was Bix. And that was in
Chicago at the Sunset behind closed doors. I
never did try to carve an ofay. Bix and I just
played for our own kicks."  You decide.
Emmett Hardy's letter to his only known girlfriend, Martha Boswell. Of
course we know the impact that Martha and her sisters Connie & Vet
made in the world of popular music. They set the standard for jazz
singing that has been copied since, but never surpassed. We can only
wonder 'what if' when it comes to Emmett Hardy. Was he as good as
they say? Ben Pollack claimed "Bix was a tin-horned soloist compared
to Emmett! Why, Emmett was so much greater, there can't be a
comparison!"  Pollack wasn't the only one who expressed this view.
Exactly one year & one day after that letter was sent to Martha
Boswell, Emmett Hardy was dead, just four days after his 22nd
birthday. Keep in mind that Emmett did not play the cornet
during the last year of his life due to illness and doctor's orders.
He made one exception - at his birthday party, four days before
his death. It was said that he blew the most beautiful blues that
you could ever imagine. Everyone was moved to tears. Truly a
classic story about a jazz legend. Of course one might ask how
could someone with advanced TB, and who hasn't  played his
horn in a year be capable of playing anything beautiful? When I
lay off for more than three days, it sounds like someone is trying
to strangle a duck. But then...I'm not Emmett Hardy.
A couple rare photos of Emmett Hardy. On the far right is
a recent discovery I made of the Brownlee Jazz Band with
Emmett from 1920. Remember that the classic photos of
Emmett were taken when he was 17 & 18 years old!
<---Really Good. Try it and see!
So..how do we find out where Emmett Hardy's true place in jazz history belongs?
Do we go by the statements of musicians who knew and played with him, and later went on
to fame themselves? Well then, let's try these on for size
. When asked to compare Bix &
Emmett, the following was the result..."Get this straight, Emmett Hardy as far back as 1919
was playing almost the identical stuff that Bix played with Goldkette & Whiteman nearly 10
yeras later...except that Emmett was more sure of himself, had more ideas, and played with
a push and drive that Beiderbecke never attained." -
PAUL MARES. "He was to music
what Shelly was to poetry." -
MARTHA BOSWELL. " The much-herealded Bix trumpet was
a bringdown to us all. We found it to be similar to Hardy's style. Nice, yes, but unoriginal
and as is usually the case, inferior to the original. Bix's and Hardy's ideas were about the
same but there was a hell of a lot of difference in the way they came out of the bells of their
horns" -
MONK HAZEL (Hazel also claimed that Bix's first two Wolverine sides were a
note-for-note copy of the way Emmett played the same tunes.) "Emmett's music was the
best. He was a gentleman as well as the greatest musician I've ever known." -
SIDNEY
ARODIN.."
I got to know Bix and hear him play. It was a thrill because Bix was the closest
man to Emmett that I ever heard and I'm taking nothing away from Bix. Bix asked me about
Emmett and told me that he learned plenty from him when he heard Emmett in Chicago. He
said he thought Emmett was the greatest." -
STEVE LOYACANO. "I roomed with Bix in
New York and I recall how he used to practice, often commenting on Hardy and how terrific a
musician he thought Hardy was. Hardy was Bix's idol and Bix gave Hardy credit for teaching
him." -
JIMMY DORSEY. "Emmett was the greatest musician I have ever heard. If ever I
can come near your son's greatness, I'll die happy." -
BIX BEIDERBECKE - In a letter to
Emmett's mother shortly after his death, unconfirmed. Whatever and
wherever the truth is about Emmett Hardy, this much is certain...Like
Bix, he left a memory to those who knew him that they carried with
them for the rest of their lives. Of course there's a story about a few
homemade cylinder records that were recorded of Emmett's playing.
Will they ever turn up? Who can say, stranger things have happened.
But in a way, I hope not. I'd hate to see Emmett's reputation get
picked apart by idiots who have never played a cornet, but do have
an agenda & a word processor, and know how to use them. Finis.
Give 'em hell, Henry! A damned fine
statement indeed. Of course it would
have been much better coming from
Wingy Manone. And speaking
of...here he is on Broadway from
1924.
In 1920 & 1921, the handwriting was
on the wall. The so-called "Jazz Age"
was almost over. Time to waltz until
you wither. Ah yes! Wayne King lives.
I used to work for someone like        
this myself! Money is a great
thing to have, true, but it can't buy
you a life. Just situations.
Now I'm all for sticking up for my fellow
musicians, but please! This guy was pistol champ
of the Russian Army. He just got dumped. He just
strangled a baby and then goes to the place
where the orchestra is playing. And they bust his
rubles about his domestic troubles! They should
have just worn T-Shirts with targets on them.
Most musicians are somewhat smart - kinda. This
bunch? I'd have to say NYET! What's the Russian
word for "dumbass" ?
I think he's got the "Mengelberg Joys"
So you want to lead a band?
Think it over.
1923 - Say it
isn't  so! But
this was
before he met
Bix.
It looks like Mr. Fink raised a stink,
served a drink and landed in the clink.
What a dink.
This is even worse than the
poor slug that got hit in the
chops with a streetcar while
playing a parade!
Ah yes! Mabel Bates. What a babe! She
really didn't get too far in the entertainment
industry. But her son Norman cut quite a
figure in films 30 years later. Mabel had a
small part herself sitting in a rocking chair.
And no jazz was played! Just violins playing
the same note over and over and over....
So the other day I'm talking to B.A Rolfe,        
and I said, "You know something? I'd sell        
my soul to get on a good label!" And he said   
"Really? I can do that for you!" It turns out     
 it wasn't really B.A. Rolfe but B.L. Zabub!
HELP!! (Editors note - If you all just start        
buying more Kazoo Lips CD's, I wouldn't         
have to do this!)
Back To Homepage
NEXT PAGE HERE